Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Clara Adler's avatar

This is a stunningly careful way to enter a fragile room without knocking anything over, the framing is tender without being precious, incisive without turning cruel. Tamara, you manage to talk about decay without turning it into either a fetish or a sermon, which is rare in a culture that can only integrate softness if it’s inspirational or profitable.

Your essay also exposes that our fear of decay isn’t really about aging or death. Witnesses is the key word here. Modern society doesn’t mind deterioration so long as it happens off-camera. What we cannot tolerate is unmanaged visibility: decline that refuses to be narrativized, monetized, or framed as “content”. We haven’t lost reverence for withering. We’ve lost patience for anything that won’t cooperate with the audience’s appetite.

There’s an unspoken social contract now, you may suffer but only if your suffering remains legible and productive. Grief must teach. Exhaustion must optimize. Aging must explain itself. Decay that doesn’t resolve into meaning is treated like a technical error. No wonder irrelevance feels like a threat.

We’ve confused being unseen with being erased.

And here’s the dark joke of it all: we call this progress!!!

We replaced vanitas with wellness, skulls with serums, mortality with maintenance. The memento mori used to humble the powerful, now it just sells them another product.

Death didn’t disappear, it got outsourced to logistics and euphemisms, while rot itself became impolite.

Your grandmother’s roses feel like the real heresy here. “They don’t ask anything of me anymore” is practically an anti-capitalist manifesto in a vase. In a world that extracts value from every expression, every feeling, every wrinkle, the idea of companionship without demand feels extraordinary. A dying flower, like an aging woman uninterested in legibility, refuses the economy entirely.

The wit of your essay is that it doesn’t beg us to admire decay. You remove the camera and let it exist. And that absence of performance is exactly what makes it unsettling. Because once beauty stops auditioning, we’re forced to ask why we needed the audition in the first place.

This is not about flowers. It’s a critique of a society that panics when nothing is being sold, recalibrated, explained, or improved.

How much depth and complexity in an essay that looks so simple. Brava!

AGK's avatar

It's tempting to mention algorithms and social media with its gild-covered rot, but I suspect that the root of this is far older. If you're in the industrialized west, you're the product of generations of people who have mostly gone their whole lives without confronting decay and death directly. We have sewage systems to dispose of waste, armies of men in trucks to dispose of refuse; people rarely die in the streets, and most will go their entire lives rarely coming into contact with a dead body or even a dead animal.

As an extension of this, we don't perform proper autopsies of success or failure. Most failures are obscured and quickly discarded like rotting carcasses; success is lionized and immortalized, as if success itself is a separate entity from failure. The obscured truth is that failure is a necessary condition for success, and is constituted as such; additionally, success has its sunset; it's not a permanent state.

We no longer honor the elderly; we don't thank the dead flowers for fulfilling their purpose and dying honorably; instead we pathologize age and hide decay, to convince ourselves that progress is linear and growth is infinite. It's pretty difficult to get people to worship money, beauty, youth and success by assessing those things honestly as being temporary in nature. Instead, it's a binary; you either ARE or you AREN'T. Wrinkled faces and dead flowers are an inconvenient reminder that you can't buy time, that beauty and health aren't forever, that success isn't always earned, that hard work isn't always rewarded, and that an audience, no matter how big, can't save you from irrelevance.

How fitting that this piece cuts and illuminates without lingering. Brief, beautiful, and retiring with dignity. It's one thing to write well, but it's another to use the structure of the work itself to embody the thesis. This is a kind of artistry that most won't recognize, but they'll feel. Well done, Tamara. This one haunts.

99 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?